Chipotle stock dips 14% as CEO Brian Niccol moves to Starbucks: Is it a buy?

Chipotle Mexican Grill’s stock has plummeted nearly 14% in early trading today following the announcement that CEO Brian Niccol will step down to take the helm at Starbucks on September 9.

Niccol, who has led Chipotle since 2018, is credited with revitalizing the company after a significant E. coli outbreak and doubling its revenue from $4.5 billion to $9.9 billion.

Niccol’s departure leaves a void at Chipotle

The abrupt shift in leadership has raised concerns among investors.

Niccol’s departure leaves a void at the top of Chipotle, a company that recently reported strong quarterly earnings.

Despite this, Chipotle’s CFO, Jack Hartung, has agreed to take on the role of president of strategy, finance, and supply chain, extending his tenure beyond his planned retirement in 2025.

Scott Maw, Chipotle’s board chairman, remains optimistic about the company’s future.

He highlighted the company’s robust talent planning and deep bench strength, ensuring that the transition will be managed smoothly.

Maw expressed confidence that the incoming CEO will inherit a well-positioned business.

Chipotle’s recent earnings report showed a notable increase in revenue and earnings per share (EPS), alongside rising foot traffic and same-store sales.

The management’s swift response to the portion size controversy, including an apology and a new system to prevent future issues, has been well-received by customers.

Starbucks welcomes Brian Niccol

In contrast, Starbucks has seen a 21% increase in its stock price following the announcement of Niccol’s appointment.

This surge comes amid significant trading volume and seems to reflect optimism about Niccol’s potential impact on Starbucks.

Mellody Hobson, Starbucks’ board chair, praised Niccol’s track record of innovation and growth, emphasizing his ability to enhance the customer and partner experience.

The departure of Starbucks’ outgoing CEO, Laxman Narasimhan, who is also stepping down from the board, coincides with the arrival of Niccol.

This move follows pressure from Elliott Investment Management, which had taken a stake in Starbucks to influence management changes.

Is it a buying opportunity?

For investors, the drop in Chipotle’s stock price following the CEO transition could present a buying opportunity.

The 14% decline comes just two weeks after a strong earnings report, suggesting that the stock’s current dip might not accurately reflect the company’s solid financial health.

Over the past five years, Niccol’s leadership has driven a remarkable 240% return for Chipotle’s stock, significantly outperforming the S&P 500’s 85% gain.

With Chipotle’s strong financial base and recent performance, the current stock price dip could be an opportune moment for long-term investors to consider increasing their holdings.

The incoming CEO will have the benefit of inheriting a well-established and profitable company, making this an intriguing time to evaluate Chipotle’s investment potential.

The post Chipotle stock dips 14% as CEO Brian Niccol moves to Starbucks: Is it a buy? appeared first on Invezz